Vonnegut and
Spiegelman possess quite a similar writing style that cannot be overlooked. One
attribute I noticed while reading was how Vonnegut and Spiegelman applied
metafiction in their work. As discussed in class, metafiction, in a nutshell, is
a writing technique that draws attention to the work of art whilst still
revealing the truth of the story. I believe Spiegelman does a great job in
using metafiction. Throughout the graphic novel, Artie is trying to write the
very book that we are reading. In Slaughterhouse-Five,
Vonnegut tells his readers in the beginning of how he wrote Slaughterhouse-Five. Thus, Vonnegut and
Spiegelman used metafiction as a way to make their stories more real rather
they did it intentionally or not.
Another similarity
they possess in their writing is how unapologetic they are when it comes to their
storytelling. In the very beginning of Slaughterhouse-Five,
Vonnegut loses a little credibility by stating that “all this happened, more or
less.” In Spiegelman’s graphic novel, we see that Artie’s father sometimes has
a difficulty time remembering which Spiegelman includes in his story which,
thereby, also loses credibility because we don’t know if anything Artie’s
father is saying is what really happened. They make no apologies for what they
include or leave out of their story which brings a certain authenticity to
their stories because it all centers on one character. Both books are about
World War II and instead of dwelling on politics and facts, they focus
primarily on one character. Slaughterhouse-Five
focuses on Billy Pilgrim whereas Maus focuses
on the life of Artie’s father, Vladek Spiegelman.
In addition,
Spiegelman and Vonnegut both view death as just a phase of life and write it as
such. Vonnegut mentions death in a casual, flippant tone with the legendary phrase, “So it goes”. This phrase
can easily be placed in Maus in some
situations as well. For example, when Artie’s father mentioned his mother’s
death. “ She was sick of cancer…and a month or two later she died.” (So it goes.)
It appears that both authors possess the same idea of death and it shows
through their work.
All in all,
Spiegelman and Vonnegut have taken a horrific, tragic event, World War II, and
altered it to encompass a story of life and loss intertwined. Maus focuses on a relationship between
father and son whereas Slaughterhouse-Five
focuses on the bombing of Dresden and Billy Pilgrim who is at war with
himself. Both Spiegelman and
Vonnegut succeed in telling their stories with as much sincerity as they can
muster. They share the same nonchalant tone and sardonic humor. Their narrative
storytelling is candid and poignant.
I really liked how you went in depth about the phrase “and so it goes” and contextualized it to Maus because that saying is my favorite part of Slaughterhouse 5 and really helps in showing Vonnegut’s view of death. Also, I liked how you stated that both are unapologetic in their writings about things left out because both are so focused on the main character, which I also found to be true. All in all, I agree completely with your opinions and enjoyed the fact that you also think that both authors are trying to tell their stories with the most sincerity they can muster.
ReplyDelete