Wednesday, January 8, 2014

How to Tell A True War Story O'Brien


If you want to know how to tell a true war story, you can’t. At least according to Tim O’Brien.  He told stories that he remembers vividly almost as if the happened the day before. Something that caught my eye was how he remembered and explained little things such as the “half step” Lemon took right before he was sucked into the booby trap. He tells us reasons how you can tell it is a true war story, but in a couple paragraphs later, explains that you cannot tell a true war story.  He recites little things, like Rat calling Lemons sister who never wrote back a cooze. Rat does not call her “bitch” or “woman”. I believe O’Brien focuses on this because he has so many awful and graphic stories that he remembers and wants to focus on all the positives that came out of very bad situations. He finds little things in like Rat not calling the woman nasty names even though he was traumatized by the death of his best friend and the fact that the sister seemed to ignore it. It is obvious that O’Brien himself is traumatized by the events that happened because he shows symptoms of PTSD. Such as when he wakes up in the middle of the night “hearing” Dave Jenson sing Lemon Tree as they pulled Lemons body off the booby trap. Or how the whole brigade seemed to be paralyzed from doing or saying anything as Rat shoots the baby buffalo. O’Brien himself even says that war stories are not believable and he even questions if they ever happened at all. In his writing it is almost like he is telling these stories for his own benefit as if to comfort him. When he tells stories and people come up to him and tell him that they were impressed or liked his story, he almost gets frustrated because the person does not get the story. They do not understand what it means to O’Brien and what he went through.

2 comments:

  1. I actually agree with James on the part about how you cant actually tell a true story because it is so intensified that everyone makes up and tells certain things that never happened. They do it in order to make the story look normal and moral. Although O’Brien said that “A true war story is never moral.” I also agree with James on the part that O’ Brien was definitely going through PSTD because he actually remembered the little details about Lemon’s death as if it happened yesterday. Because he mentions the “half step” that he remembers Lemon took before he got caught up in the booby trap. I actually understand now why PSTD is a common disorder for war soldiers.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "When he tells stories and people come up to him and tell him that they were impressed or liked his story, he almost gets frustrated because the person does not get the story. They do not understand what it means to O’Brien and what he went through. " to elaborate on this I think this at the heart of what O'Brien is trying to write about. He wants to tell a True War Story, but it is impossible for him to convey this truth to someone who has not experienced war. It is the struggle every vet must feel because there is no way, through images, words, and reconstructions to actually show what the war is like. And when people say they liked his story, he must not care or even think that his story telling skills have something to do with it. He is thinking about the content of the story, and the moral to come out of it, because how can someone claim to like war?

    ReplyDelete